Want to help decipher an archaeological mystery?

A very interesting incised design appears on an ancient potsherd found in the sifting of the soil from the Temple Mount . Is it the Temple Menorah? Some kind of floral design? Something else? How can we date this potsherd? When was the incision done? By whom and for what purpose?

If it is a menorah, what can we learn from this artifact?

All these questions are currently being debated by the archaeologists studying this potsherd.

We welcome your suggestions…

27239 menorah-c

0 replies
« Older CommentsNewer Comments »
  1. Werekoala2000
    Werekoala2000 says:

    Rotate 90′ to the right, and it looks like it might be a stick-figure representation of someone blowing a multi-headed trumpet. The right-angle crook would be the arm holding the horn(s). The full image may have implied many people in rank blowing trumps, like you see in many older paintings.

    Would help if we knew if there was any indication as to what the “correct” orientation of the piece is, if that’s even possible.

    Reply
  2. CJ
    CJ says:

    This is a crude depiction of the temple mount Menorah as described by the Rambam/Maimonides. The sign was more then likely as a decoration and therefore isn’t very detailed and is missing the cups the Rambam describes. His opinion is that the Menorah had straight branches and that the Menorah depicted on Titus’s’ arch was actually just a candelabra possibly from the Women’s section.

    Reply
  3. Josh
    Josh says:

    I see an Olive Tree with 5 branches that, from the viewer’s perspective, is standing to the left of what appears to be a simple depiction of a house. Notice what might be an angled roof line, eave, and partial wall on the right of the potsherd.

    This could also be a depiction of a five branched Menorah to follow tradition of the time as I’ve read recently that rabbis prevented making seven branched Menorahs like the one in the temple. It could also be artistic license.

    http://www.biblicalarchaeology.org/daily/biblical-sites-places/temple-at-jerusalem/understanding-the-jewish-menorah/

    Nevertheless, this is in line with the premise that this may have been part of a simple artistic depiction of the two witnesses of Revelation/Zechariah. In other words, I can see this potsherd being the left hand side of a larger image interpreting the two Olive Trees (or perhaps two Lampstands) standing before the Lord/God of the earth. The artistic image to have in mind is something similar to an Olive Tree (or Menorah) standing on the left AND right of the house of God from the viewer’s perspective.

    The below is a discussion of the many interpretations regarding the witnesses. This is one of many including the imagery of the Olive Trees. I’ll leave any further interpretations to each reader.

    http://endtimepilgrim.org/twowit.htm

    Interestingly, from this perspective, the fact that this potsherd has been uncovered is amazing to me. And what we may be viewing (from my own personal perspective) is the depiction of this concept with Jesus Christ if full view – who, from a Biblical perspective, sits at the right hand of the Father.

    Reply
  4. Polly (@Smampoo)
    Polly (@Smampoo) says:

    Looks like a Hebrew letter from Ruth 3:11. – And now, my daughter, fear not: all that thou sayest I shall do to thee, for it is on all hands known in the gate of my people that thou art a truly capable woman. The word חָיִל in the expression אֵשֶׁת ךחיִל has no synonym in English, is understood as capable and heroic, virtuous.

    Reply
  5. raystetler
    raystetler says:

    As you go down the bottom angle of the item, at the bottom of the vertical incision, there is an incised line at 90°out about 3 mm then down. If the design is some sort of plant, that bottom form could represent a planter of some sort. If, as some assume, it is a Temple Menorah then wouldn’t the design show an horizontal bar to which the stems then go up instead of six (visible) appendages? The main question that I believe should be the main focus is: in the Torah, is there mention of a design similar to this that would have been on an earthen vessel or, being possibly dating c. 300-1450, is there history, written or traditional, that could explain a ceremonial vessel from even the early Christian church? As far as seeing a two dimensional image I can only speculate whether the pie is flat or has a slight curved surface. My best wishes to you in solving this mystery.

    Reply
  6. Ann Kime
    Ann Kime says:

    It appears to be a palm leaf held over the right shoulder of a person whose forehead and eyes are visible on the slanted broken edge.

    Reply
  7. Luis Bermudez
    Luis Bermudez says:

    Hi, if it’s not a menorah, maybe instead it could be a type of whip that was used to punish prisoners as they did with some of the apostles?

    Reply
  8. Stanley
    Stanley says:

    It is an apothecary pottery sign..showing the type of Medicine or herbal remedy inside the medicine pot. This looks to be False Queen Anns lace..i.e greater Ammi ( Ammi magus)..This was used for psoriasis or some sort of skin condition remedy. Or to treat vitiligo..Or it could be Cumin or dill. The shard sign is an identification of this herb or remedy…Thanks for allowing us to possibly help…

    Reply
    • James
      James says:

      Could be at this point it’s a Archeologically Rorschach test. But pots were created to hold things and very often even today symbols related to what they made to hold are put on them. I’ve seen sugar jars with bee’s and beehives painted on them. Flour Jars with pictures of bread. Tea jars with Tea leaves or Tea cups painted on them. Since Dates and Date sugar were stable products it kind of makes a logical sense that it would be a picture related to what the jar was made to hold.

      Reply
  9. Brett
    Brett says:

    wrong orientation? looks like its done on a potters wheel,? so the lines should go around the pot not up and down? Guess right 90 degrees, done by a right handed person as the far left line has a kink in at which would happen if right handed

    Reply
« Older CommentsNewer Comments »

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply